March 2007

G.R. No. 150335/G.R. No. 152687.  March 1, 2007

E. V. Yu, et al. Vs.The Orchard Gold & Country Club, Inc, et al./E. V. Yu, et al. Vs. The CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 153874.  March 1, 2007

Titan Construction Corp. Vs. Uni-Field Enterprises, Inc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 164893.  March 1, 2007

C. Duldulao Vs. The CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 150986.  March 2, 2007

Clark Devt. Corp. Vs. Mondragon Leisure & Resorts Corp., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 153413.  March 2, 2007

N. S. Raniel, et al. Vs. P. Jachico, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 153456.  March 2, 2007

R. Padua Vs. The Hon. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 153936.  March 2, 2007

R. M. Reyes Vs. Alsons Devt. & Investment Corp., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 158253.  March 2, 2007

RP etc. Vs. C. Lacap etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 166865.  March 2, 2007

A. F. Buenaventura, et al. Vs. RP.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167261.  March 2, 2007

R. L. Paqng-et Vs. C. Manacnes-Dao-as etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169570.  March 2, 2007

R. Portuguez Vs. GSIS Family Bank, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 171063.  March 2, 2007

E. V. Tugade Vs. COMELEC, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 138965.  March 5, 2007

Public Interest Center, Inc., et al. Vs. Magdangal B. Elma, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 148111.  March 5, 2007

Gil Justalero, et al. Vs. Zenaida San Agustin-Gonzales, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 154591.  March 5, 2007

Manila Hotel Enterprises Asso. etc. Vs. Manila Hotel Corp.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 156055.  March 5, 2007

R. R. Paredes, et al. Vs. T. S. Calilung.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 156527.  March 5, 2007

N. M. Calim Vs. The Hon. J. F. Guerrero, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 164307.  March 5, 2007

Sps. Rodelio & A. Poltan Vs. BPI Family Savings Bank, Inc., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168301.  March 5, 2007

A. B. Monfort III, et al. Vs. Ma. A. M. Salvatierra, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. MTJ-04-1531.  March 6, 2007

P. dela Cruz, et al. Vs. Judge P. B. Vallarta etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. MTJ-06-1655.  March 6, 2007

L. R. Ocampo Vs. Hon. G.M. Bibat-Palamos etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 150194.  March 6, 2007

R. Tayaban, et al. Vs. Pp et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 153477.  March 6, 2007

Del MontePhil., Inc. Vs. L. Velasco.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 154243.  March 6, 2007

Dep. Dir. Gen. R. Lastimoso, et al. Vs. P/Sen. Insp. J. J. Asayo.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 162927.  March 6, 2007

M. B. Agoy, et al. Vs. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 163359.  March 6, 2007

The Industrial Technology etc. Vs. R. M. Villanueva etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167989-93.  March 6, 2007

T. M. Jumamil, et al. Vs. COMELEC, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169604.  March 6, 2007

N. P. Collantes Vs. Hon. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 171314.  March 6, 2007

Pp Vs. P. Oliquino.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 156052.  March 7, 2007

Social Justice Society, et al. Vs. Atienza, Jr.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.C. No. 7204.  March 7, 2007

C. Advincula Vs. Atty. E. M. Macabata.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. 07-2-26-MTC.  March 7, 2007

Absence w/o official leave of Ms. M. T. V. Almirante.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. MTJ-04-1530.  March 7, 2007

F. Palon, Jr. Vs. Judge P. Vallarta etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 147594.  March 7, 2007

Metro Manila Transit Corp. Vs. D.M. Consortium, Inc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 148182.  March 7, 2007

U. Maglente, et al. Vs. Hon. P. Baltazar-Padilla etc et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 149053.  March 7, 2007

Central Surety & Insurance Co. Vs. Planters Products Inc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 156249.  March 7, 2007

M. Rivera, et al. Vs. E. A. Turiano, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 162053.  March 7, 2007

St. Luke’s Medical Center etc. Vs. NLRC, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167714.  March 7, 2007

Rowell Industrial Corp. Vs. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167760.  March 7, 2007

Manila Jockey Club Employees etc. Vs. Manila Jockey Club, Inc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170849.  March 7, 2007

Pp Vs. E. Moran, Jr. y Gordula.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 171354.  March 7, 2007

M. B. Tolentino, M.D. Vs. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 172369.  March 7, 2007

Pp Vs. E. Lopez, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 173310/G.R. No. 173609.  March 7, 2007

A. J. Abubakar Vs. House of Representatives etc., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 174199.  March 7, 2007

Pp Vs. R. alarcon y Tioxon.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 174551.  March 7, 2007

Mayor S. A. Jainal Vs. COMELEC, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 171952.  March 8, 2007

Diego T. Lim Vs. COMELEC.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 164819.  March 9, 2007

Jerty Pascual Contreras etc. Vs. The Hon. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 166309-10.  March 9, 2007

RP etc. Vs. Unimex Micro-Electronics GMBH.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168818.  March 9, 2007

N. Sabang Vs. Pp.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169933.  March 9, 2007

Su Zhi Shan Vs. Pp/Sol. Gen.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170384-85.  March 9, 2007

L. Dising Punzal Vs. ETSI Technologies, Inc., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.C. No. 6377.  March 12, 2007

Rufa C. Suan Vs. Atty. Ricardo D. Gonzales.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. MTJ-06-1636.  March 12, 2007

J. B. Verzosa Vs. Judge M. E. Contreras etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. RTJ-06-1979.  March 12, 2007

N. Cagas Vs. Judge R. B. Torrecampo etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 159669/G.R. No. 163521.  March 12, 2007

United Overseas Bank Phils. Vs. Rosemor Mining & Devt. Corp., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 165685.  March 12, 2007

R. R. Pilares, Sr. Vs. PP.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 166719.  March 12, 2007

Si1angan Textile Mfg. Corp., et al. Vs. Hon. A. C. Demetria, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167512.  March 12, 2007

V. L. Enterprises and/or F. J. Visitacion Vs. Hon. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169890.  March 12, 2007

F. Esguerra, et al. Vs. V. Trinidad, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170346.  March 12, 2007

Heirs of Nicolas Jugalbot etc. Vs. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 163212.  March 13, 2007

Candano Shipping Lines, Inc. Vs. F. J. Sugata-on.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169304.  March 13, 2007

The Dept. of Health, et al. Vs. Phil. Pharmawealth, Inc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169397.  March 13, 2007

RP Vs. R. Sarmiento.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. 04-5-20-SC.  March 14, 2007

In Re: Affidavit of Frankie N. Calabines etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. 02-1-12-SC.  March 14, 2007

In re: request of Justice B. P. Pardo etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 171020.  March 14, 2007

Pp Vs. A. Pangilinan.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169494.  March 14, 2007

Cabalen Mgt. Co., Inc., et al. Vs. J. P. Quiambao, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168913.  March 14, 2007

R. Ting Vs. Heirs of D. Lirio etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167137.  March 14, 2007

A. A. Arbonida Vs. COMELEC, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 127301.  March 14, 2007

Dept. of Budget and Mgt., et al. Vs. The City Govt of Cebu.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 149603.  March 14, 2007

Estate of Lim Ching etc. Vs. F. Bacala, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168253/G.R. No. 172741.  March 16, 2007

Mayor N. E. Rosal, Vs. COMELEC, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 128587.  March 16, 2007

People Vs. Hon. Perfecto A.S. Laguio, Jr. et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 154878.  March 16, 2007

Carolyn M. Garcia Vs. Rica Marie S. Thio.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 156934.  March 16, 2007

Alpha C. Jaculbe Vs. Silliman University.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 161886.  March 16, 2007

Filipinas Port Services Inc., et al. Vs. Victoriano S. Go, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170284.  March 16, 2007

Benito Aratea and Ponciana Canonigo Vs. Esmeraldo P. Suico and CA.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 145526.  March 16, 2007

Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development Corp. Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. 06-6-8-CA/A.M. No. 06-44-CA-J.  March 20, 2007

RE: Complaint Against Justice Elvi John S. Asuncion of the Court of Appeals.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 147191.  March 20, 2007

Sps. Manuel & Luisa Tan Lee, et al. Vs. Hon CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167314.  March 20, 2007

Luisito O. Cumigad Vs. Comelec, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168512.  March 20, 2007

Orlando D. Garcia, Jr., et al. Vs. Ranida Salvador, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 173484.  March 20, 2007

People Vs. Simeon Suyat Y. Jose.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 174194.  March 20, 2007

People Vs. Edwin Ausa.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-06-2154.  March 22, 2007

Robert R. Pascua Vs. Atty. Angel P. Beltran etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 144950-71.  March 22, 2007

Blas Baldebrin, et al. Vs. Sandiganbayan, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 148117.  March 22, 2007

Mabini Epie, Jr. et al. Vs. The Hon. Nelsonida T. Ulat-Marredo.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 150640.  March 22, 2007

Barangay Sindalan, et al. Vs. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 152430.  March 22, 2007

Samahang Magsasaka Ng 53 Hectarya etc. Vs. Wilfredo Mosquera, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 154721.  March 22, 2007

Alfonso Firaza Vs. People of the Phil.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 154837.  March 22, 2007

Ang Brat Huan Sons Industries, Inc. Etc. Vs. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 157593.  March 22, 2007

Sps. Alberto & Jocelyn Azana Vs. Cristopher Lumbo, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 157629.  March 22, 2007

J & N Shipping Lines, Inc. Vs. Technomarine Co., Ltd., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 160540.  March 22, 2007

Vicia D. Pascual Vs. People of the Phil.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 160741.  March 22, 2007

Herminia Cando Vs. Sps. Aurora Olazo etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 161823.  March 22, 2007

Sony Computer Entertainment, Inc. Vs. Supergreen, Inc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 166105.  March 22, 2007

Atty. Gabriel B. Octava Vs. Comelec, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167492.  March 22, 2007

Jaime M. De Guzman Vs. People of the Phil.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169204.  March 23, 2007

Adelaida Escobar, et al. Vs. Ligaya Oligario Luna, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 172226.  March 23, 2007

The People of the Phil. Vs. Herminigildo Senieres.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 173243.  March 23, 2007

The People of the Phil. Vs. Artemio Casela.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 175946.  March 23, 2007

People of the Phil. Vs. Raymundo Dadulla.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 154877.  March 27, 2007

Jin-Jin Delos Santos Vs. Sps. Reynato D. Sarmiento et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 155208.  March 27, 2007

Nene Lazalita Tating Vs. Felicidad Tating Marcella et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 155682.  March 27, 2007

Banco Filipino Savings & Mortgage Bank Vs. CA et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 163768.  March 27, 2007

Julius Ka Wachi, et al. Vs. Dominie Del Quero et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170823.  March 27, 2007

Dept of Agrarian Reform etc. Vs. Oroville Devt. Corp etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 171756.  March 27, 2007

Sps. Ricardo Imbat etc. Vs. Sps. Medardo Soliven etc., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 173290.  March 27, 2007

Zenaida M. Limbona Vs. Hon. Judge Ralph S. Lee et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 176158.  March 27, 2007

People of the Phil. Vs. Rolando Cabinan.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.C. No. 4306.  March 28, 2007

Remberto C. Kara-An Vs. Atty. Reynaldo A. Pineda.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 133110.  March 28, 2007

Barstowe Phil. Corp. Vs. Republic of the Phil.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 153726/ G.R. No. 154014.  March 28, 2007

Republic of the Phil. Vs. Democrito Mendoza, Sr., et al. / Silot Bay Fisherman's Asso. Inc. Vs. Republic of the Phil. etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 157202.  March 28, 2007

PLDT, Inc. Vs. Amparo Balbastro, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 157959.  March 28, 2007

Heirs of Vicente Reyes etc. et al. Vs. The Hon. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 162864.  March 28, 2007

Sps. Peblia Alfaro & Prosperous Alfaro Vs. Hon. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 164547.  March 28, 2007

CGP Transportation & Services Corp. Vs. PCI Leasing & Finance Inc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 164582.  March 28, 2007

Pilar Espina, et al. Vs. Hon. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 164820.  March 28, 2007

Victory Liner, Inc. Vs. Pablo M. Race.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 166558.  March 28, 2007

Nora Bueno Pasion Vs. Simplicio R. Melegrito etc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169116.  March 28, 2007

BPI Vs. Sps. Ireneo M. Santiago etc. et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169129.  March 28, 2007

Sps. Virgilio F. Santos etc. et al. Vs. Sps. Jose Lumbao & Proserfina Lumbao.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169731.  March 28, 2007

Alfredo Barba, et al. Vs. Hon. CA, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 175316.  March 28, 2007

People of the Phil. Vs. Roger Durano.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 164273.  March 28, 2007

Emmanuel B. Aznar Vs. Citibank, N.A.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169596.  March 28, 2007

Superlines Transportation Co., Inc. Vs. PNCC, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 154765.  March 29, 2007

Pedro T. Bercero Vs. Capitol Devt. Corp..

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 163706.  March 29, 2007

Divine Word College of San Jose, et al. Vs. Herminia G. Aurelio.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 172278.  March 29, 2007

Lydia R. Pagaduan Vs. COMELEC, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 157221.  March 30, 2007

Pp Vs. Cesar Galvez.

Concurring Opinion

J. Yanres-Santiago

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 164398.  March 30, 2007

Alicia C. Maranan Vs. Manila Banking Corp.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169514.  March 30, 2007

Confederation of Sugar Producers Asso., Inc., et al. Vs. Dept. of Agrarian Reforms et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING