August 2010

G.R. No. 179743. August 2, 2010 Hadja Fatima Gaguil Magoyag, joined by her husband, Hadjihasan Madlawi Magoyag Vs. Hadji Abubacar Maruhom 

G.R. No. 183140. August 2, 2010 North Bulacan Corporation Vs. Philippine Bank of Communications 

G.R. No. 184603. August 2, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Romeo Labagala y Abigonia, Alvin Labagala y Juat and Richard Allan Alejo y Sigasig 

G.R. No. 154622. August 3, 2010 Land Bank of the Philippines Vs. Ramon P. Jacinto 

G.R. No. 176354. August 3, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Wilson Lopez, et al. 

G.R. No. 178778. August 3, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. T/Sgt. Porferio R. Angus, Jr. 

A.C. No. 8481. August 3, 2010 Atty. Josabeth V. Alonso, et al. Vs. Atty. Ibaro B. Relaminda, Jr. 

G.R. No. 150666. August 3, 2010 Luciano Briones and Nelly Briones Vs. Jose Macabagdal, Fe D. Macabagdal and Vergon Realty Investments Corporation 

G.R. No. 158929. August 3, 2010 Rosario P. Tan Vs. Artemio G. Ramirez, et al. 

G.R. No. 154662. August 3, 2010 Land Bank of the Philippines Vs. Ramon P. Jacinto 

G.R. No. 162025. August 3, 2010 Tunay na Pagkakaisa ng Manggagawa sa Asia Brewery Vs. Asia Brewery, Inc. 

G.R. No. 170847. August 3, 2010 Government Service Insurance System Vs. Felicitas Zarate, as substited by her heirs, namely Melanie Zarate, et al. 

G.R. No. 179498. August 3, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Rustico Bartolin y Ampis 

G.R. No. 187104. August 3, 2010 Saint Louis University, Inc. Vs. Evangeline C. Cobarrubias 

G.R. No. 190696. August 3, 2010 Rolito Calang and Philtranco Service Enterprises, Inc. Vs. People of the Philippines 

G.R. No. 182677. August 3, 2010 Jose Antonio C. Leviste Vs. Hon. Elmo M. Alameda, et al. 

G.R. No. 165321. August 3, 2010 Ricardo P. Toring Vs. Teresita M. Toring and Republic of the Philippines 

G.R. No. 182364. August 3, 2010 AT&T Communications Services Philippines, Inc. Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue 

G.R. No. 183891. August 3, 2010 Romarico J. Mendoza Vs. People of the Philippines 

A.M. No. MTJ-09-1743. August 3, 2010 Josephine Sarmiento, et al. Vs. Hon. Aznar D. Lindayag, et al. 

G.R. No. 182789. August 3, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Norlito Sambahon y Nueva 

G.R. No. 179333. August 3, 2010 Josephil C. Bien Vs. Pedro B. Bo 

G.R. No. 161083. August 3, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Hon. Basilio R. Gabo, et al. 

G.R. No. 166411. August 3, 2010 Elpidio Calipay Vs. National Labor Relations Commission, et al. 

G.R. No. 168103. August 3, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Alejandro Rellota y Tadeo 

G.R. No. 169569. August 3, 2010 Ramon Torres and Jessie Belarmino Vs. Spouses Vihinzky Alamag and Aida A. Ngo 

G.R. No. 171033. August 3, 2010 City Mayor, et al. Vs. Rizal Commercial Banking Corporation 

G.R. No. 186529. August 3, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Jack Racho y Raquero 

G.R. No. 188197. August 3, 2010 Leonardo U Flores Vs. Hon. Raul S. Gonzales 

G.R. No. 181970/G.R. No. 182678. August 3, 2010 Bernardo De Leon Vs. Public Estates Authority Substituted by the City of Parañaque, Ramon Arellano, Jr., Ricardo Pena and Reymund Orpilla/Public Estates Authority (now Philippine Reclamation Authority) substituted by the City of Parañaque Vs. Hon. Selma Palacio Alaras, in her capacity as the acting Presiding Judge of Branch 135, Regional Trial Court of Makati City, and Bernardo De Leon 

A.M. No. P-02-1625. August 4, 2010 Office of the Court Administrator Vs. Marina Garcia Pacheco, COC, MCTC, Paete, Laguna 

G.R. No. 152092. August 4, 2010 Pilipino Telephone Corporation Vs. Radiomarine Network, Inc. 

G.R. No. 178609. August 4, 2010 Manuel P. Ney and romulo P. Ney Vs. Sps. Celso P. Quijano and Mina N. Quijano 

G.R. No. 151454. August 8, 2010 Heirs of Antonio Santos, et al. Vs. Heirs of Crispulo Beramo, et al. 

G.R. No. 168672. August 8, 2010 Equitable PCI Bank, Inc. Vs. DNG Realty and Development Corporation 

G.R. No. 169170. August 8, 2010 D.M. Consunji, Inc. Vs. Antonio Gobres, et al. 

G.R. No. 170693. August 8, 2010 Emilia Micking Vda. De Coronel, et al. Vs. Miguel Tanjangco, Jr. 

G.R. No. 171630. August 8, 2010 Century Canning Corporation, Ricardo T. Po, Jr., et al. Vs. Vicente Randy R. Ramil 

G.R. No. 171643. August 8, 2010 Filemon A. Verzano, Jr. Vs. Francis Vitor D. Paro 

G.R. No. 172276. August 8, 2010 Soceite Des Produits Nestle, S.A. Vs. Martin T. Dy, Jr. 

G.R. No. 172541. August 8, 2010 Jay Hidalgo Uy Vs. Spouses Francisco Medina and Natividad Medina, et al. 

G.R. No. 172589. August 8, 2010 Jeffrey Nacague Vs. Sulpicio Lines, Inc. 

G.R. No. 173900. August 8, 2010 Gaudencio Labrador represented by Lulu Labrador Uson as Attorney-in-Fact Vs. Spouses Ildefonso Perlas and Pacencia Perlas, et al. 

G.R. No. 175837. August 8, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Leonito Amatorio 

G.R. No. 180836. August 8, 2010 Gilbert Urma, et al. Vs. Hon. Orlando Beltran, et al. 

G.R. No. 182937. August 8, 2010 Ernesto Villeza Vs. German Management and Services, Inc., et al. 

G.R. No. 185091. August 8, 2010 Republic of the Philippines Vs. Primo Mendoza and Maria Lucero 

G.R. No. 187741. August 8, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Peter M. Campomanes and Edith Mendoza 

A.M. No. RTJ-08-2139. August 6, 2010 Michael B. Belen Vs. Judge Medel Arnaldo B. Belen, Regional Trial Court, Branch 36 Calamba City 

A.M. No. RTJ-10-2242. August 6, 2010 Atty. Raul L. Correa Vs. Judge Medel Arnaldo B. Belen, Regional Trial Court, Branch 36 Calamba City 

G.R. No. 159355. August 9, 2010 Gabriel C. Singson, et al. Vs. Commission on Audit 

G.R. No. 164538. August 9, 2010 Metropolitan Bank and Trust Company Vs. Rogelio Reynaldo and Jose C. Adrandea 

G.R. No. 171115. August 9, 2010 Nagkakaisang Lakas ng Manggagawa sa Keihin (NLMK-OLALIA-KMU) and Helen Valenzuela Vs. Keihin Philippines Corporation 

G.R. No. 179441. August 9, 2010 St. James College of Parañaque; Jaime T. Torres, represented by his legal representative, James Kenley M. Torres; and Myrna M. Torres Vs. Equitable PCI Bank 

G.R. No. 180915. August 9, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Charlie Nazareno y Melanios 

G.R. No. 182877. August 9, 2010 SCA Hygiene Products Corporation Employees Association-FFW Vs. SCA Hygiene Products Corporation 

G.R. No. 189818. August 9, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Michael Lindo y Vergara 

G.R. No. 187698. August 9, 2010 Rodolfo J. Serrano Vs. Severino Santos Transit and/or Severino Santos 

G.R. No. 160828. August 9, 2010 Picop Resources Incorporated (PRI) Vs. Anacleto L. Tañeca, et al. 

G.R. No. 163582. August 9, 2010 William Golangco Construction Corporation Vs. Ray Burton Development Corporation 

G.R. No. 189092. August 9, 2010 People of the Phililppines Vs. Melvin Lolos 

G.R. No. 165770. August 9, 2010 Heirs of Francisca Medrano, namely Yolanda R. Medrano, et al. Vs. Estanislao De Vera 

G.R. No. 175315. August 9, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Elizer Beduya and Ric Baduya 

G.R. No. 181244. August 9, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Anita "Kenneth" Trinidad 

G.R. No. 186533. August 9, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Efren Castillo 

G.R. No. 179859. August 9, 2010 in Re: Petition for probate of last will and testament of Basilio Santiago, et al. Vs/ Zoilo S. Santiago, et al. 

G.R. No. 180761. August 9, 2010 Roman Garces Vs. Simplicio Hernandez, et al. 

G.R. No. 183352. August 9, 2010 Heirs of Jose M. Cervantes, et al. Vs. Jesus G. Miranda 

G.R. No. 187288. August 9, 2010 Spouses Braulio Navarro and Cesaria Sindao Vs. Perla Rico go 

A.C. No. 5835/A.C. No. 6051/A.C. No. 6441/A.C. No. 6955. August 10, 2010 Carlos Reyes Vs. Atty. Jeremias R. Vitan/Celia Arroyo-Posidio Vs. Atty. Jeremias R. Vitan/Violeta Tahaw Vs. Atty. Jeremias R. Vitan/Mark Yuson Vs. Atty. Jeremias R. Vitan 

G.R. No. 157383/G.R. No. 174137. August 10, 2010 Winston F. Garcia Vs. Mario I. Molina, et al./Winston F. Garcia Vs. Mario I. Molina, et al. 

G.R. No. 158708. August 10, 2010 Justina Maniebo Vs. Hon. CA & Civil Service Commission 

G.R. No. 164301. August 10, 2010 Bank of the Philippine Islands Vs. BPI Employees Union-Davao Chapter-Federation of Unions in BPI Unibank 

Dissenting Opinion

J. Capio, J. Brion

G.R. No. 167606. August 11, 2010 Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. Fort Bonifacio Development Corporation 

G.R. No. 137794/G.R. No. 149664. August 11, 2010 Erlinda Reyes and Rosemarie Matienzo Vs. Hon. Judge Belen B. Ortiz, et al./Sps. Alberto Embores and Lourdes Embores, et al. Vs. Hon. Raymundo G. Vallega, et al. 

G.R. No. 176066. August 11, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Estela Tuan y Baludda 

G.R. No. 162291. August 11, 2010 Bank of the Philippines Island Vs. Shemberg Biotech Corporation and Benson Dakay 

G.R. No. 165950. August 11, 2010 Equitable PCI Bank, Inc. Vs. OJ-Mark Trading, Inc. and Spouses Oscar and Evangeline Martinez 

G.R. No. 180665. August 11, 2010 Sps. Paulino Atienza and Rufina Atienza Vs. Domingo P. Espidol 

G.R. No. 174979 & G.R. No. 175010. August 11, 2010 Bonifacio Sanz Maceda, Jr. Vs. DBO / DBP Vs. Bonifacio Sanz Maceda, Jr. 

G.R. No. 174806. August 11, 2010 Soloil, Inc. Vs. Philippine Coconut Authority 

G.R. No. 172880. August 11, 2010 China Banking Corporation Vs. Cebu Printing and Packaging Corporation 

G.R. No. 175578. August 11, 2010 Republic of the Philippines Vs. Zenaida Guinto, in her own behalf and as Attorney-in-fact of Ma. Aurora Guinto-Comiso, et al. 

G.R. No. 168842. August 11, 2010 Vicente Go Vs. Metropolitan Bank and Trust Co. 

G.R. No. 186979. August 11, 2010 Socorro Limos, et al. Vs. Sps. Francisco and Arwenia Odones 

G.R. No. 173219-20. August 11, 2010 ALC industries, Inc. Vs. Department of Public Works and Highways 

G.R. No. 158298. August 11, 2010 Isidro Ablaza Vs. Republic of the Philippines 

G.R. No. 161834. August 11, 2010 Land Bank of the Philippines Vs. Heir of Trinidad S. Vda. De Arieta 

G.R. No. 157049. August 11, 2010 Citytrust Banking Corporation Vs. Carlos Romulo N. Cruz 

G.R. No. 170830. August 11, 2010 PHIMCO Industries, Inc. Vs. PHIMCO Industries Labor Association (PILA), et al. 

G.R. No. 186571. August 11, 2010 Gerbert Corpuz Vs. Daisylyn Tirol Sto. Tomas and the Solicitor General 

A.M. No. RTJ-09-2211. August 12, 2010 Evangeline Vera cruz Vs. Judge Winston M. Villegas 

G.R. No. 153736. August 12, 2010 Spouses Nicanor Tumbokon, et al. Vs. Apolonia G. Legaspi adn Paulina S. De Magtanum 

G.R. No. 177105-06. August 12, 2010 Jose Reyes y vacio Vs. People of the Philippines 

G.R. No. 179029. August 12, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Felimon Pagaduan y Tamayo 

G.R. No. 154124. August 13, 2010 National Tobacco Administration Vs. Daniel Castillo 

G.R. No. 158377. August 13, 2010 Heirs of Jose Reyes, jr. namely; Magdalena C. reyes, et al. Vs. Amanda S. Reyes, et al. 

G.R. No. 149588. August 16, 2010 Francisco R. Llamas and Carmelita C. Llamas Vs. The Hon. Court of Appeals, et al. 

G.R. No. 188271. August 16, 2010 Jesus E. Dycoco, Jr. Vs. Equitable PCI Bank (now Banco de Oro), Rene Bunaventura and Siles Samalea 

G.R. No. 185848. August 16, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Michael Sembrano y Castro 

G.R. No. 190216. August 16, 2010 Arnold F. Anib Vs. Coca-Cola Bottlers Phils., Inc. (CCBPI) and or Rhogie Feliciano 

G.R. No. 190065. August 16, 2010 Dermaline, Inc. Vs. Myra Phamaceuticals, Inc. 

G.R. No. 185122. August 16, 2010 Wensha Spa Center, inc. and/or Xu Zhi Jie 

G.R. No. 172604. August 17, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Venancio Roxas y Arguelles 

G.R. No. 182094. August 18, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Efren Alfonso 

G.R. No. 183688. August 18, 2010 Land Bank of the Philippines Vs. Rizalina Gustilo Barrido, et al. 

G.R. No. 185286. August 18, 2010 Ma. Socorro Camacho-Reyes Vs. Ramon Reyes 

G.R. No. 171982. August 18, 2010 Development Bank of the Philippines Vs. Traders Royal Bank, et al. 

G.R. No. 175116. August 18, 2010 Jerry Ong Vs. Philippine Deposit Insurance Corp. 

G.R. No. 186094. August 23, 2010 Paciencia A. Deleon, et al. Vs. Ma. Catalina P. Tan, et al. 

G.R. No. 165339. August 23, 2010 Equitable PCI Bank Vs. Arcelito B. Tan 

G.R. No. 172724. August 23, 2010 Pharmacia and Upjohn, Inc., et al. Vs. Ricardo p. Albayda, Jr. 

G.R. No. 182779. August 23, 2010 Victorina (Victoria) Alice Lim Lazaro Vs. Brewmaster International, Inc. 

G.R. No. 189971. August 23, 2010 Freddie Cabildo Vs. People of the Philippines 

G.R. No. 186175. August 23, 2010 3A Apparel Corporation and Ray Shu Vs. Metropolitan Bank and Trust Co., et al. 

A.M. No. 07-1-05-RTC. August 23, 2010 Re: Request of Judge Salvador Ibarreta, Jr., RTC, Br. 8, Davao City, for extension of time to decide 

G.R. Nos. 153952-72. August 23, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. The Hon. Sandiganbayan and Mayor Henry Barrera 

A.C. No. 6258. August 24, 2010 Luzviminda R. Lustestica Vs. Atty. Sergio E. Bernabe 

A.M. No. 08-19-SB-J. August 24, 2010 Assistant Special Prosecutor III Rohermia J. Jamsani-Rodriguez Vs. Justice Gregory S. Ong, et al. 

Dissenting Opinion

J. Abad

G.R. No. 176951/G.R. No. 177499/G.R. No. 178056. August 24, 2010 League of Cities of the Phil. rep by LCP National President Jerry P. Trenas, et al. Vs. COMELEC, et al. 

Dissenting Opinion

J. Velasco

G.R. Nos. 162335 & 162605. August 24, 2010 Severino M. Manotok IV, et al. Vs. Heirs of Homer L. Barque represented by Teresita Barque Hernandez 

Dissenting Opinion

J. Carpio, J. Sereno

Concurring and Dissenting Opinion

J. Carpio Morales

G.R. No. 174269. August 25, 2010 Polo S. Panteleon Vs. American Express International, Inc. 

G.R. No. 186557. August 25, 2010 Negros Metal Corporation Vs. Armelo J. Lamayo 

G.R. No. 189091. August 25, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Arman Apacible Rodriguez 

G.R. No. 170414/G.R. No. 170418/G.R. No. 170460. August 25, 2010 Government Service Insurance System Vs. Pacific Airways Corporation, et al./Philippine Airlines, Inc., et al. Vs. Pacific Airways Corporation, et al./Air Transportation Office, et al. Vs. Pacific Airways corporation, et al. 

G.R. No. 174593. August 25, 2010 Alex Gurango Vs. Best Chemicals and Plastic, Inc., et al. 

G.R. No. 177970. August 25, 2010 Agricultural and Industrial Supplies Corporation, et al. Vs. Jueber P. Siazar, et al. 

G.R. No. 154152. August 25, 2010 La Campana Development Corporation Vs. Arturo Ledesma, et al. 

G.R. No. 173089. August 25, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Hon. Enrique C. Asis, etc., et al. 

G.R. No. 186192. August 25, 2010 The heirs of Mateo Pidacan and Romana Bigo, namely:Pacita Pidacan Vda de Zubiri, et al. Vs. Air Transporation office, represented by its Acting Director Beinvenido Manga 

G.R. No. 168387. August 25, 2010 Salun-at Marquez, et al. Vs. Eloisa Espejo, et al. 

G.R. No. 179045-46. August 25, 2010 Commissioner of Internal Revenue Vs. Smart Communication, Inc. 

G.R. No. 182010. August 25, 2010 Susan Esquillo y Romines Vs. People of the Philippines 

Dissenting Opinion

J. Bersamin

G.R. No. 169345. August 25, 2010 Dee Ping Wee, Araceli Wee & Marina U. Tan Vs. Lee Hiong Wee & Rosalind Wee 

G.R. No. 175784. August 25, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Jaime Ayochok y Tauli 

G.R. No. 182526. August 25, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Leonardo Degay y Undalos 

G.R. No. 185206. August 25, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Manuel Aguilar 

G.R. No. 188315. August 25, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Isidro Flores y Lagua 

G.R. No. 188330. August 25, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Rogelio J. Rosialda 

G.R. No. 151168. August 25, 2010 Cebu Autometric Motos, Inc. Vs. Tirso Uytengsu III 

G.R. No. 156125. August 25, 2010 Francisco Muñoz, Jr. Vs. Erlinda Ramirez, et al. 

G.R. No. 159275. August 25, 2010 Republic of the Philippines Vs. The Hon. Sandiganbayan, et al. 

G.R. No. 165442. August 25, 2010 NASECO Guards Association - PEMA Vs. National Service Corporation 

G.R. No. 165641. August 25, 2010 Engr. Ranulfo C. Feliciano Vs. Hon. Cornelio C. Gison 

G.R. No. 170146. August 25, 2010 Hon. Waldo Q. Flores, et al. Vs. Atty. Antonio F. Montemayor 

Dissenting Opinion

J. Bersamin

G.R. No. 171015. August 25, 2010 Continental Watchman and Security Agency, Inc. Vs. National Food Authority 

G.R. No. 174084. August 25, 2010 Spic n' Span Services Corp. Vs. Gloria Paje, et al. 

G.R. No. 186526. August 25, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Federico Campos y Ranile 

G.R. No. 165153. August 25, 2010 Carlos De Castro Vs. Liberty Broadcasting Network, Inc. and Edgardo Quigue 

A.M. No. P-10-2837. August 25, 2010 PO2 Patrick Mejia Gabriel Vs. William Jose R. Ramos 

G.R. No. 188328. August 25, 2010 People of the Philippines Vs. Joselito Nasara y Dahay 

G.R. No. 179577. August 25, 2010 Von Madarang y Montemayor Vs. People of the Philippines 

G.R. No. 182651/G.R. No. 182657. August 25, 2010 Heirs of Jane Honrales Vs. Jonathan Honrales / People of the Philippines and Heirs of Jane Honrales Vs. Jonathan Honrales 

A.M. No. P-06-2132. August 25, 2010 Presentation V. Anota Vs. Agerico P. Balles, Clesrk of Court IV, MTCC, Tacloban, Leyte 

G.R. No. 191988. August 31, 2010 Atty. Evillo C. Pormento Vs. Joseph "Erap" Ejercito Estrada and COMELEC