December 2006

G.R. No. 148014.  December 5, 2006

Spouses Antonio Vizarra and Brenda Logatoc Vizarra, et al. Vs. Conchita R. Rodriguez, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170232.  December 5, 2006

Vette Industrial Sales Co., Inc., et al. Vs. Sui Soan S. Cheng.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 172259.  December 5, 2006

Sps. Jaime Benos and Marina Benos Vs. Sps. Gregorio Lawilao and Janice Gail Lawilao.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-06-2114.  December 5, 2006

Anonymous Vs. Lourdes C. Grande.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168340.  December 5, 2006

Rafael Gonzales Vs. Hon. Tranquil P. Salvador.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 129098.  December 6, 2006

Amelia Cabrera Vs. Manuel Lapid, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 131260.  December 6, 2006

Santos Ventura Hocorma Foundation, Inc. Vs. Richard V. Funk.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 136433.  December 6, 2006

Antonio B. Baltazar Vs. Honorable Ombudsman, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 139442.  December 6, 2006

Lourdes Dela Cruz Vs. Court of Appeals, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 143527.  December 6, 2006

United Field Sea Watchman and Checkers Agency, et al. Vs. Willie Requillo, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 146322.  December 6, 2006

Ernesto Ramas Uypitching, et al. Vs. Ernesto Quiamco.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 147832.  December 6, 2006

People of the Philippines Vs. Danilo P. Gabriel.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 148423.  December 6, 2006

Esperanza G. Frondarina Vs. Napoleon Malazarte, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 152440.  December 6, 2006

Felicitacion B. Borbajo Vs. Hidden View Homeowners, Inc., et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 159751.  December 6, 2006

Gaudencio E. Fernando, et al. Vs. Court of Appeals.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 164575.  December 6, 2006

Robert P. Wa-Acon Vs. People of the Philippines.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 166854.  December 6, 2006

Semirara Coal Corporation Vs. Hgl Development Corporation, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168649.  December 6, 2006

People of the Philippines Vs. Jose Alvizo Audine.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 173054.  December 6, 2006

People of the Philippines Vs. Elmercito Manalo y Dulay.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-06-2172.  December 6, 2006

Re: Report on the Judicial Audit Conducted In the Regional Trial Court.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-06-2270.  December 6, 2006

LBC Bank Vigan Branch Vs. Carlos Q. Guzman, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.C. No. 6517.  December 6, 2006

Marcos V. Prieto Vs. Atty. Oscar B. Corpuz, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 138939.  December 6, 2006

Mr. and Mrs. Alejandro Pang-Oden Vs. Isabel Leonen, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 142439.  December 6, 2006

Filinvest Land, Inc. Vs. Court of Appeals, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

Dissenting Opinion

J. Ynares-Santiago

G.R. No. 143491.  December 6, 2006

Republic of the Philippines Vs. Efren M. Carrasco.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 147566.  December 6, 2006

San Miguel Corporation Vs. National Labor Relations Commission and Rafael Maliksi.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 148021.  December 6, 2006

Sime Darby Employees Association, et al. Vs. National Labor Relations Commission, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 153193.  December 6, 2006

Pamplona Plantation Company Vs. Ramon Acosta, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 154469.  December 6, 2006

Metropolitan Bank and Trust Company Vs. Renato D. Cabilzo.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 154493.  December 6, 2006

Reynaldo Villanueva Vs. Philippine National Bank.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 154628.  December 6, 2006

Estrellita G. Salazar Vs. Philippine Duplicators, Inc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 155392.  December 6, 2006

Erlinda Guanzon Vs. Andrew P. Arradaza, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 155488.  December 6, 2006

Erlinda R. Velayo-Fong Vs. Spouses Raymond and Maria Hedy Velayo.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 157632.  December 6, 2006

Jose S. Roque, Jr. Vs. Jaime T. Torres, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 161007.  December 6, 2006

Celerino Sanchez Vs. People of the Philippines.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 163089.  December 6, 2006

Republic of the Philippines Vs. Jesus Francisco, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 163509.  December 6, 2006

Picop Resources, Inc. Vs. Base Metals Mineral Resources Corporation, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 164888.  December 6, 2006

Rural Bank of Coron, Inc., et al. Vs. Annalisa Cortes.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 166769.  December 6, 2006

Manila Electric Company, Inc. Vs. Genaro Lualhati, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168156.  December 6, 2006

Heirs of Rosendo Lasam Vs. Vicenta Umengan.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168628.  December 6, 2006

People of the Philippines Vs. Emeterio Ricamora y Suello.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169141.  December 6, 2006

People of the Philippines Vs. Romeo Del Mundo y Sta. Maria.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169372.  December 6, 2006

Narciso Guiang Vs. Court of Appeals, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169453.  December 6, 2006

Capitol Steel Corporation Vs. Phividec Industrial Authority.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170092.  December 6, 2006

Xavierville III Homeowners Association, Inc. Vs. Xavierville II Homeowners Association, Inc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 171017.  December 6, 2006

People of the Philippines Vs. Zosimo Aguila y Atienza.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-06-2277.  December 6, 2006

Romel Flores Vs. Juan C. Marquez.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. RTJ-05-1907.  December 6, 2006

Executive Judge Edwin A. Villasor Vs. Judge Rodolfo R. Bonifacio, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-06-2244.  December 6, 2006

Saga Design, Inc. Vs. Atty. Emeline B. Cabahug.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170132.  December 6, 2006

Government Service Insurance System, et al. Vs. Kapisanan Ng Mga Manggagawa Sa GSIS.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 163878.  December 12, 2006

Far East Bank and Trust Company Vs. Shemberg Marketing Corporation, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 163584.  December 12, 2006

Remelita M. Robinson Vs. Celita B. Miralles.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168444.  December 13, 2006

People of the Philippines Vs. Romeo Canare y Mendoza.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 132925.  December 13, 2006

Marcial Sienes, et al. Vs. People of the Philippines.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-01-1478.  December 13, 2006

Mary Ann C. Ito Vs. Eric B. De Vera, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 153031.  December 14, 2006

PCL Shipping Philippines, Inc., et al. Vs. National Labor Relations Commission, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 165732.  December 14, 2006

Safeguard Security Agency, Inc., et al. Vs. Lauro Tangco, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 166315.  December 14, 2006

Alfredo Sy, et al. Vs. Hon. Secretary of Justice, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 173421.  December 14, 2006

Oscar Z. Benares Vs. Josephine Lim.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 140687.  December 18, 2006

China Banking Corporation Vs. Court of Appeals, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 158261.  December 18, 2006

In Re: Petition for Assistance in the liquidation of the Rural Bank of Bokod (Benguet), Inc. Vs. Bureau of Internal Revenue.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 166177.  December 18, 2006

Herbert Williams Vs. Court of Appeals, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 168071.  December 18, 2006

Luciano Tan Vs. Rodil Enterprises.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.C. No. 6128.  December 19, 2006

Rosemarie L. Hsieh Vs. Atty. Salvador Quimpo, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 142625.  December 19, 2006

Rogelio P. Nogales, et al. Vs. Capitol Medical Center, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 149190.  December 19, 2006

Felicisimo L. Opriasa, et al. Vs. The City Government of Quezon City.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 155679.  December 19, 2006

Biflex Phils. Inc. Labor Union, et al. Vs. Filflex Industrial and Manufacturing Corporation, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 157875.  December 19, 2006

Dr. Teresita L. Salva Vs. Guillermo N. Carague, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 159794.  December 19, 2006

Maclaring M. Lucman Vs. Alimatar Malawi, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 161950.  December 19, 2006

Florencio B. Campomanes Vs. People of the Philippines.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 167812.  December 19, 2006

Jesus M. Gozun Vs. Jose Teofilo T. Mercado.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 171901.  December 19, 2006

First United Constructors Corporation Vs. Court of Appeals, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-06-2124.  December 19, 2006

Report on the status of the financial audit conducted in the Regional Trial Court.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-06-2284.  December 19, 2006

Engracio M. Escasinas, Jr. Vs. Gary G. Lawas.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 126619.  December 20, 2006

Uniwide Sales Realty and Resources Corporation Vs. Titan-Ikeda Construction and Development Corporation.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 153674.  December 20, 2006

Avon Cosmetics, Incorporated, et al. Vs. Leticia H. Luna.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 164358.  December 20, 2006

Theresa Macalalag Vs. People of the Philippines.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

A.M. No. P-06-2269.  December 20, 2006

Office of the Court Administrator Vs. Edgardo Montalla.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 128099.  December 20, 2006

Felix Camitan, et al. Vs. Court of Appeals, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 166704.  December 20, 2006

Agrifina Aquintey Vs. Sps. Felicidad and Rico Tibong.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 166862.  December 20, 2006

Manila Metal Container Corporation Vs. Reynaldo C. Tolentino / Philippine National Bank Vs. Dmci-Project Developers, Inc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 169251.  December 20, 2006

Demie L. Uriarte Vs. People of the Philippines.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 170563.  December 20, 2006

Sps. Pedro And Paz Surtida Vs. Rural Bank of Malinao (Albay), Inc.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING

G.R. No. 162447.  December 27, 2006

Anabelle Muaje-Tuazon and Almer R. Abing Vs. Wenphil Corporation, et al.

SUMMARY OF THE VOTING