Republic of the Philippines

Supreme Court

Manila

Summary of Voting

Title	League of Cities of the Philippines (LCP) represented by LCP National President Jerry P. Treñas, et al., vs., Commission on Elections, et al., City of Tarlac, et al., Petitioners-In-Intervention, League of Cities of the Philippines (LCP) represented by LCP National President Jerry P. Treñas, et al., vs., Commission on Elections, et al., League of Cities of the Philippines (LCP) represented by LCP National President Jerry P. Treñas, et al., vs., Commission on Elections, et al.,	Ponente	J. Carpio
Docket No.	G.R. No. 176951/ G.R. No. 177499/ G.R. No. 178056	No. of Participating Justices	11
Date of Promulgation	November 11, 2008	Unanimous Decision (Yes/No)	No

Concurring Justices		Comments e.g. separate opinion (SO), joined SO, reservations
1	J. Quisumbing
2	J. Austria-Martinez
3	J. Carpio Morales
4	J. Velasco, Jr.
5	J. Brion
6
7
8
9
10
11
12		-
13		-
14		-
15

Dissenting Justices		Comments e.g. dissenting opinion (DO), joined DO
1	J. Corona	I join the dissent of J. Ruben Reyes.
2	J. Azcuna	I join the dissent of Justice Ruben Reyes
3	J. Chico-Nazario	I join the dissent of Justice Ruben Reyes
4	J. Reyes	Pls. see Dissenting Opinion
5	J. Leonardo-De Castro	I join the dissent of Justice Ruben T. Reyes
6	-	-
7	-	-

Justices Not Participating		Reason e.g. on official leave
1	CJ. Puno	No part
2	J. Ynares-Santiago	On leave
3	J. Tinga	No part. Close relation to an interested entity.
4	J. Nachura	No part.
5	-	-
6	-	-
7	-	-