Republic of the Philippines

Supreme Court

Manila

 

Summary of Voting

 

Title

Tondo Medical Center Employees Association, Research Institute For Tropical Medicine Employees Association, National Orthopedic Workers Union, Dr. Jose R. Reyes Memorial Hospital Employees Union, San Lazaro Hospital Employees Association, Alliance Of Health Workers, Inc., Health Alliance For Democracy, Council For Health Development, Network Opposed To Privatization, Community Medicine Development Foundation Inc., Philippine Society Of  Sanitary Engineers Inc., Kilusang Mayo Uno, Gabriela, Kilusang Magbubukid Ng Pilipinas, Kalipunan Ng Damayan Ng Mga Maralita, Elsa O. Guevarra, Arcadio B. Gonzales, Jose G. Galang, Domingo P. Manay, Tito P. Esteves, Eduardo P. Galope, Remedios M. Ysmael, Alfredo Bacuņata, Edgardo J. Damicog, Remedios M. Maltu and Remegio S. Mercado v. The Court of Appeals, Executive Secretary Alberto G. Romulo, Secretary of Health Manuel M. Dayrit, Secretary of Budget and Management Emilia T. Boncodin

Ponente

J. Chico-Nazario

 

Docket No.

G.R. No. 167324

No. of Participating Justices

13

Date of Promulgation

July 17, 2007

Unanimous Decision (Yes/No)

Yes

 

Concurring Justices

Comments

e.g. separate opinion (SO), joined SO, reservations

1

C.J. Puno

-

2

J. Quisuming

-

3

J. Ynares-Santiago

-

4

J. Sandoval-Gutierrez

-

5

J. Carpio

-

6

J. Austria-Martinez

-

7

J. Corona

-

8

J. Carpio Morales

-

9

J. Azcuna

-

10

J. Tinga

-

11

J. Chico-Nazario

-

12

J. Garcia

-

13

J. Velasco, Jr.

-

 

 

-

 

 

 

 

Dissenting Justices

Comments

e.g. dissenting opinion (DO), joined DO

1

-

-

2

-

-

3

-

-

4

-

-

5

-

-

6

-

-

7

-

-

 

 

Justices Not Participating

Reason

e.g. on official leave

1

J. Nachura

No part. Filed pleading as SolGen

2

-

-

3

-

-

4

-

-

5

-

-

6

-

-

7

-

-