Republic of the Philippines

Supreme Court

Manila

 

Summary of Voting

 

Title

Leah M. Nazareno, Carlo M. Cual, Rogelio B. Clamonte, Florecita M. Llosa, Rogelio S. Villarubia, Ricardo M. Gonzales, Jr., Rossel Marie G. Gutierrez, Nicanor F. Villarosa, Jr., Marie Sue G. Cual, Miramichi Majella B. Mariot, Alma F. Ramirez, Antolin D. Zamar, Jr., Mario S. Aliling, Teodulo Salvoro, Jr., Philip Janson Altamarino, Anonietta Padura, Adolfo R. Cornelia, Ian Ryan Patula, William Tanoy, Victor Arbas, Jeanith Cual, Braulio Sayson, Dawn M. Villarosa, Agustin A. Rendoque, Enriqueta Tumongha, Lionel P. Banogon, Rosalito Vergantinos, Mario T. Cual, Jr., Elaine May Tumongha, Norman F. Villarosa, Ricardo C. Patula, Rachel Banagua, Rodolfo Calugcugan, Pergentino Cual, Bernard J. Ozoa, Roger John Aromin, Cheryl E. Nocete, Marivic Sanchez, Crispin Duran, Rebeco Lincgong, Ana Lee Estrabella, Melchor B. Maquiling, Raul Molas, Oscar Kinikito, Darwin B. Conejos, Romel Cual, Roqueta D. Amor, Diosdado B. Lajato, Paul E. Pino, Lito C. Piņero, Rodulfo Zosa, Jr., and Jorge Arbolado v. City of Dumaguete, represented by Hon. Mayor Agustin R. Perdices, Dominador Dumalag, Jr., Erlinda Tumongha, Josephine Mae Flores, and Araceli Campos

Ponente

J. Nachura

Docket No.

G.R. No. 168484

No. of Participating Justices

4

Date of Promulgation

July 12, 2007

Unanimous Decision (Yes/No)

Yes

 

Concurring Justices

Comments

e.g. separate opinion (SO), joined SO, reservations

1

J. Ynares-Santiago

-

2

J. Austria-Martinez

-

3

J. Chico-Nazario

-

4

J. Nachura

-

 

 

-

 

 

-

 

 

-

 

 

-

 

 

-

 

 

-

 

 

-

 

 

-

 

 

-

 

 

-

 

 

 

 

 

Dissenting Justices

Comments

e.g. dissenting opinion (DO), joined DO

1

-

-

2

-

-

3

-

-

4

-

-

5

-

-

6

-

-

7

-

-

 

Justices Not Participating

Reason

e.g. on official leave

1

-

-

2

-

-

3

-

-

4

-

-

5

-

-

6

-

-

7

-

-